Bayside City Council in Melbourne has officially adopted the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) definition of antisemitism, becoming the second local council in Victoria to take this significant step. The council voted unanimously during its meeting on Tuesday night, with all councillors present supporting the motion.
The measure, led by Councillor Robert Irlicht who moved the motion, aims to address antisemitism at the local level and foster social cohesion. The Jewish Community Council of Victoria (JCCV) expressed gratitude towards Councillor Irlicht and Councillor Andrew Hockley, who seconded the motion, emphasizing their commitment to working with council staff to implement effective strategies.
Local Impact and Security Concerns
During the debate, Councillor Irlicht highlighted the urgency of addressing antisemitism, describing it as a “local crisis.” He stated, “Jewish kids face slurs at the Melbourne Museum, abuse echoes on Nepean Highway and Hampton Street. The Ripponlea Synagogue firebombing, which is a terrorist act, jolts us all.” He firmly rejected attempts to conflate antisemitism with geopolitical issues, asserting, “This isn’t about the Middle East. It’s not about Israel. This is not about Gaza.”
Councillor Hockley reiterated the local nature of the initiative, underscoring the practical security needs of Jewish institutions. He noted that local churches and schools lack adequate security measures, which potentially exposes them to danger. “In my ward, the Sacred Heart Church does not have ram-proof doors,” he said, highlighting the pressing need for improved safety.
Councillor Kylie McIntosh presented alarming statistics, noting that there were 552 recorded incidents of antisemitism in Victoria last year, a number that likely underrepresents the actual occurrences.
Controversy and Opposition
Despite the unanimous support within the council, the motion faced criticism from a group known as Jews for Justice Melbourne. This collective expressed concerns that the IHRA definition would stifle legitimate political discourse regarding Israel, specifically its actions in Gaza. Led by Rosie Heselev, the group advocated for the Jerusalem Declaration on Antisemitism as a more suitable alternative.
Councillor Irlicht responded to these criticisms, asserting that the claims made by the group were “factually incorrect” and “dangerously obfuscating.” He dismissed fears about potential surveillance measures or funding cuts as “utter nonsense,” insisting that the council’s focus remains on safety without compromising civil liberties.
The council’s decision adds to the growing recognition of antisemitism as a serious issue, joining Glen Eira Council, which has the largest Jewish population in Victoria, in formally adopting the IHRA definition.
The JCCV, led by CEO Naomi Levin, has collaborated with over 20 local councils in Victoria to combat antisemitism, providing training and guidance on the IHRA definition. Levin emphasized the importance of these initiatives, stating, “This includes providing cultural and antisemitism training, advice and guidance on the IHRA definition of antisemitism and other useful tools.”
As Bayside City Council moves forward with its commitment, it aims to create a safer environment for all residents, particularly those within the Jewish community. The unanimous vote reflects a broader recognition of the need to confront antisemitism, ensuring that the safety and dignity of all community members are upheld.
