British Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer has endorsed calls for Prince Andrew to appear before Members of Parliament (MPs) to discuss his living arrangements at the Royal Lodge. Recent revelations indicate that Prince Andrew has not paid rent on the 30-room mansion located on the Windsor Estate for over two decades. Instead, he has only been obligated to pay a nominal annual fee, often referred to as “peppercorn” rent.
The issue gained traction following a question posed by Sir Ed Davey, leader of the Liberal Democrats, during Prime Minister’s Questions. He urged Starmer to support a parliamentary inquiry into the Crown Estate, which oversees the Royal Lodge, emphasizing the need to protect taxpayer interests. “Will the prime minister support a select committee inquiry, so all those involved can be called for evidence, including the current occupant?” Davey asked. Starmer responded affirmatively, stating, “It’s important, in relation to all Crown properties, that there is proper scrutiny, and I certainly support that.”
Royal Lodge, situated within 40 hectares of secluded grounds in Great Windsor Park, has come under fire from various MPs. The Guardian reported that members of the public accounts committee, which monitors public spending, are advocating for an investigation into the matter. Although it is uncommon for a royal family member to testify before MPs, there are no formal rules preventing such a request.
Nonetheless, British parliamentary procedures may complicate matters. Questions that could “cast reflections on the sovereign or the royal family” are typically deemed inadmissible, which could limit the scope of any inquiry.
The scrutiny surrounding Prince Andrew intensified this week following the release of a memoir by his late accuser, Virginia Giuffre, who alleged she had sexual encounters with him on three occasions. Prince Andrew has consistently denied these allegations. In 2022, he settled a lawsuit with Giuffre for an undisclosed amount. Tragically, Giuffre died by suicide in April 2023 in Western Australia.
In a significant development, Prince Andrew recently announced he was relinquishing his royal titles and honors after discussions with King Charles and other family members. The ongoing controversy has sparked widespread criticism from MPs across the political spectrum, raising questions about the transparency of royal finances.
Former Labour government minister Baroness Margaret Hodge voiced her concerns on BBC Radio 4’s Today program, stressing that royal finances are “mired in secrecy.” She stated, “If there has been a sweetheart deal with Prince Andrew, there is less money going to the taxpayer, but we don’t know. There’s no transparency. So inevitably, we’re sceptical and we ask questions.”
The Liberal Democrats have demanded that Prince Andrew repay “every penny of rent that he’s not paid while disgracing his office.” In a further escalation of the debate, Conservative MP Robert Jenrick has called for Prince Andrew’s removal from Royal Lodge, suggesting he should “leave public life forever.”
This scandal comes at a sensitive time for the royal family, particularly as King Charles and Queen Camilla prepare for a state visit to the Vatican to meet Pope Leo. Buckingham Palace has noted that this visit will mark a historic moment in relations between the Catholic Church and the Church of England, highlighting the importance of maintaining a positive public image.
As this story unfolds, the implications for royal accountability and transparency in public spending remain significant, with both supporters and critics calling for a thorough examination of the facts surrounding Prince Andrew’s living arrangements.
