Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has addressed recent personal attacks from Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who labelled him a “weak politician” in a social media post. This exchange follows rising diplomatic tensions between Australia and Israel, particularly after the Australian government denied a visa to far-right Israeli politician Simcha Rothman.
The visa denial was part of a decision to prevent Rothman from participating in a speaking tour organized by a fringe Jewish group in Australia. In retaliation, the Israeli government revoked visas for three Australian representatives to the Palestinian Authority and instructed embassy staff to apply increased scrutiny to Australian visa applications.
Albanese responded to Netanyahu’s remarks during a press conference in Adelaide on October 25, 2023. He stated, “I don’t take these things personally. I engage with people diplomatically. (Netanyahu) has had similar things to say about other leaders.” Albanese emphasized the need for a global resolution to the ongoing cycle of violence, asserting that this is what Australians desire.
In a separate statement, Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke criticized Netanyahu, suggesting that the Israeli leader was reacting negatively to his increasing isolation among Western leaders. Burke remarked, “Strength is not measured by how many people you can blow up or how many children you can leave hungry.” He praised Albanese for his approach, highlighting the importance of direct communication with Netanyahu regarding Australia’s positions on sensitive issues.
The revocation of the Australian diplomats’ visas was justified by Israel’s Foreign Minister Gideon Sa’ar, who cited Australia’s decision to recognize Palestine and the refusal to grant visas to Rothman and former Israeli minister Ayelet Shaked as reasons for this measure.
Concerns about the deteriorating relationship between Australia and Israel have been voiced within the Jewish community. Josh Burns, a Labor MP and member of the Jewish community, described Netanyahu’s language as a “poor reflection” and called for a more measured tone from Burke. He urged all parties to take a moment for reflection, stating, “What’s really important is that everyone take a big, deep breath.”
Opposition Leader Sussan Ley emphasized the need for Albanese to outline a clear plan for repairing diplomatic ties with Israel. She noted that respect should be mutual, stating, “What has happened is that the relationship has deteriorated, and that failure is becoming apparent.” Ley pointed out that the current situation is regrettable for both nations.
The Executive Council of Australian Jewry, represented by co-chief executive Alex Ryvchin, expressed concern over the escalating tensions. He urged for a reduction in public insults, stating, “None of this is served or advanced through this public exchange of insults.” Ryvchin reassured that the Jewish community does not feel abandoned by the Australian government, despite Netanyahu’s criticisms.
As diplomatic discussions continue, the outcomes of these exchanges may significantly impact the future relationship between Australia and Israel. Both leaders face the challenge of navigating complex international dynamics while addressing the concerns of their respective nations.
