Sean “Diddy” Combs has returned to court in Manhattan as he seeks to overturn a jury’s verdict that found him guilty of prostitution charges. The hip-hop mogul, aged 55, faces a potential sentence of up to 20 years in prison if his conviction from July 2, 2024, is upheld. While jurors cleared Combs of more serious charges including sex trafficking and racketeering, they determined that he paid male escorts to travel across state lines for sexual encounters with his girlfriends, which he filmed.
As Combs entered the courtroom of US District Judge Arun Subramanian, he appeared relaxed, smiling and greeting his family and legal team. The judge has not yet indicated when he will make a decision regarding Combs’ appeal.
In a filing dated July 30, Combs’ lawyers argued that he did not engage in sexual acts himself during what were described as “Freak Offs,” drug-fueled sex marathons. They contended that filming these encounters constituted “amateur pornography,” which they claim is protected under the First Amendment of the US Constitution.
The prosecution, represented by the Manhattan US Attorney’s office, countered that Combs did not need to participate directly in the sexual acts to be found guilty. They argued that his facilitation of the male escorts’ travel and his alleged use of the films for blackmail—threatening to release them if his girlfriends withdrew from the encounters—were sufficient for conviction.
Trial Highlights and Testimonies
Combs, who is widely recognized for his influence on hip-hop culture as the founder of Bad Boy Records, was arrested on sex trafficking charges on September 16, 2024. His trial, which lasted two months, featured testimonies from two former girlfriends, including musician Casandra Ventura, known as Cassie. Both women alleged that Combs physically assaulted them and threatened to withdraw financial support if they refused to participate in the sexual performances.
Although Combs’ legal team acknowledged the accusations of physical violence, they argued that there was no direct connection between such actions and the women’s consent to participate in the encounters. They maintained that both women engaged willingly, motivated by their affection for Combs.
The hearing presented an opportunity for both the prosecution and defense to make their cases, with each side allotted 20 minutes to present their arguments. Judge Subramanian requested clarification on whether Combs could have raised his First Amendment defense earlier in the proceedings.
Next Steps and Sentencing
Should Judge Subramanian uphold the conviction, Combs is scheduled to be sentenced on October 3, 2024. In a recent court document, his lawyers suggested a 14-month sentence, which would allow for his release soon, considering the time he has already served. The prosecution is expected to submit its own sentencing recommendation by September 29, 2024.
As the case unfolds, the implications for Combs’ career and public image remain significant. The outcome of this hearing could reshape not only his future but also the broader conversation surrounding consent and power dynamics in the entertainment industry.
