The first day of the 2025 MLB Draft concluded with unexpected selections that have left analysts and fans buzzing. The Washington Nationals made headlines by choosing Eli Willits, a high school shortstop, as the No. 1 pick. This decision came as a surprise, given the absence of a consensus top prospect in this year’s draft. The Seattle Mariners capitalized on an unexpected opportunity, securing Kade Anderson, the No. 1-ranked prospect according to ESPN’s Kiley McDaniel, at the No. 3 spot.
As the evening unfolded, the choices made by various teams revealed a mix of strategic planning and bold risks. The Los Angeles Angels selected Tyler Bremner at No. 2, a decision that raised eyebrows since McDaniel had ranked him 18th. Analysts noted that the draft’s unpredictable nature was evident in the early picks, especially with the Nationals’ and Angels’ choices.
Analysis of Top Picks
ESPN baseball insiders weighed in on the implications of these selections. Alden Gonzalez expressed his astonishment at both the Nationals and Angels’ decisions. He noted that the Nationals’ choice of Willits, particularly after the recent firing of GM Mike Rizzo, caught many by surprise. Gonzalez pointed out that while Willits may not have been a widely projected first overall pick, his potential as a cost-saving selection could allow the Nationals more flexibility later in the draft.
Jesse Rogers echoed this sentiment, emphasizing the uncertainty surrounding the draft. He remarked that trusting a 17-year-old’s development could be risky but might pay off if Willits matures into a reliable player. The Angels’ choice of Bremner, a college pitcher, also sparked debate. Rogers suggested that while Bremner may help the team in the short term, his selection might have been influenced by the need for quicker impact players.
Notable Selections and Surprises
The draft also featured several noteworthy picks beyond the top two. The Colorado Rockies selected Ethan Holliday, son of former MLB player Matt Holliday, at No. 4. This choice was well-received, marking a sentimental moment for the franchise. Another surprising selection was Ethan Conrad, who went No. 17 to the Chicago Cubs despite concerns over his health following shoulder surgery.
Billy Carlson’s selection by the Chicago White Sox at No. 10 was highlighted as a potential steal by Rogers. Despite a challenging previous season, Carlson’s defensive skills and power potential could significantly benefit the White Sox as they rebuild. The Pittsburgh Pirates, meanwhile, opted for high school pitcher Seth Hernandez at No. 6, a choice that raised questions given the team’s pressing need for hitting.
As the draft progresses, teams are expected to focus on acquiring talent that can develop into impactful players. The strategies employed during Day 1 suggest a trend towards prioritizing high school prospects, particularly those playing shortstop, as teams seek to enhance their rosters with athleticism and versatility.
The first day of the 2025 MLB Draft has set a compelling tone for the remainder of the event. With teams making bold choices and exploring new strategies, fans and analysts alike will be watching closely to see how these young athletes develop in the years to come.
