UPDATE: Hay Shire Council has just approved a controversial development application for an unmanned fuel station, igniting a firestorm of anger among local residents. The decision, made during a heated council meeting on December 1, 2025, came after a tie vote that prompted Mayor Carol Oataway to exercise her casting vote.
The packed gallery erupted in outrage as the approval was announced, leading to chaos both inside and outside the Council Chambers. Residents shouted profanities at councillors, and tensions escalated when threats were directed at the General Manager. This urgent situation highlights deep community divides over safety and environmental concerns related to the proposed fuel station on Moama Street.
This controversial fuel station, proposed by bulk diesel supplier IOR, had previously been rejected by the council in June due to significant opposition from neighbors. Despite amendments aimed at improving safety and aesthetics, residents like Tony Domaille expressed serious concerns regarding traffic safety. “There have been so many near misses from trucks on this road, it’s unbelievable,” Domaille stated, emphasizing the need for a robust access road to accommodate the anticipated daily influx of 30 trucks.
Community speaker Julie Lawrence reminded councillors that approving the application would breach their own stated values, which emphasize community welfare and safety. “These values are meant to protect and enhance our community,” she warned. The emotional pleas continued, with local resident Sharon Hicks detailing the logistics of heavy vehicle traffic and its potential dangers, urging the council to reconsider.
Key amendments to the proposal include a new 2.4m high acoustic fence and enhanced landscaping to mitigate noise and visual impact. Despite these alterations, councillors voting in favor of the application—Crs Perry, Chapman, and Oataway—expressed concerns about possible legal repercussions if the application was rejected. In contrast, Crs Miller, Garner, and Porter voiced their opposition, highlighting the development’s lack of benefits for the town.
The council’s decision is set to be re-evaluated, as a rescission motion has been filed and will be discussed at the council’s December meeting. General Manager David Webb confirmed this development, indicating that community members will have another chance to voice their concerns.
The escalating tensions surrounding this fuel station application underscore a significant clash between development interests and community safety. Residents remain vigilant, and the outcome of the upcoming meeting could redefine the future of South Hay and its commitment to protecting local values. Follow this developing story for more updates.
